In determining whether or not an item is classified as “real property” or “personal property,”?

In determining whether or not an item is classified as “real property” or “personal property,” which of the following tests are NORMALLY considered?
A.Manner of attachment, intention of the party who made the attachment, purpose for which the item is used.
B.Manner of attachment, size of the item, cost of the item.
C.The number of items in question, current market value, purpose for which the item(s) is used.
D.Who owns the item, manner of attachment, size of item.

Answer:
Manner of attachment is the primary question in deciding whether it stays with the property or goes with the owner of the thing.

We used to say if it's screwed or glued or would cause damage if removed, it stays.

I think the "intentions" would be least important consideration (since intentions should be stated, in writing, in the contract).

Example: a large and decorative mirror hanging in the bathroom, over the lavatory-- Probably personal property if hanging on a picture hanging. Probably real property if the drywall would be damaged with removal.
A. It's an item on the exam test, and something you need to know to practice. Of course it doesn't help without considering that they must be attached to an interest in LAND, be in fee simple, condominium, or whatever.
If the item is attached to the structure or the ground, it stays with the house. However, there are some gray area that causes a lot of problems. A lamp that is hung on the ceiling by a hook but the lamp is plucked into a wall socket instead of wired to a light switch may be a personal property instead of a fixture. A refrigerator with a wall pluck but without a ice maker is considered a personal property. However, if it is hooked in permanently with a water line for an ice maker, then it is a fixture.

To avoid these kind of down to the bare knuckle fights over an egg beater at closing, the best way to handle is to list all the items in the sales agreement or attach an inventory sheet so that there is absolutely no mistake between the parties what goes and what stays.
As Searchlight stated, it's A. Think of the name "MARIA" when thinking of fixtures:
Method of attachment
Adaptability of the item
Relationship of the Parties
Intention of the parties
Agreement between the parties

Regards

The answers post by the user, for information only, BAnswer.com does not guarantee the right.

Other Questions and Answers:
  • Paying cash for a car then buying a house?
  • Can you live in Maidstone and work in London?
  • If you are only 2 months behind in your second mortgage and none in your first can the 2nd still forclose?
  • When you buy a house, do you usually give the asking price, above the asking or how do you know?
  • Does anybody, preferably someone who resides in San Diego, CA know tenant's rights.?
  • do u think I can purchase or get financing?
  • Anybody know of any websites.?
  • who can I rent from when I have a recent eviction?